Comparative Analysis of Rives-Stoppa versus Onlay Mesh Repair Techniques for Incisional Hernia: A Prospective Study
Keywords:
Incisional hernia, mesh repair, Rives-Stoppa technique, onlay repair, surgical outcomesAbstract
Background: Incisional hernia represents a significant complication following abdominal surgery with an incidence of approximately 20%. This study compares the outcomes of retromuscular prefascial mesh placement versus onlay mesh repair in incisional hernia surgery.
Methods: A prospective comparative study was conducted at Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Hospital, Warangal, from August 2022 to July 2024. Fifty patients with incisional hernia were randomly allocated into two equal groups: Group A underwent retromuscular prefascial mesh placement (Rives-Stoppa technique) and Group B underwent onlay mesh repair. Inclusion criteria included age 15-65 years, defect size <20 cm, and fitness for anesthesia. Primary outcomes included recurrence rates and postoperative complications. Secondary outcomes included operative parameters and patient satisfaction.
Results: The study population comprised 32 females and 18 males with mean age 44.6±10.5 years. Obstetric surgeries accounted for 62% of previous operations. The prefascial group showed significantly higher perioperative hemorrhage rates (28% vs 4%, p=0.04) but significantly lower postoperative infection rates: superficial wound infection (4% vs 32%, p=0.02) and deep wound infection (4% vs 28%, p=0.04). Overall early postoperative complications were lower in the prefascial group (24% vs 60%, p=0.01). No recurrence occurred in the prefascial group compared to 4% in the onlay group during follow-up.
Conclusion: While both techniques are effective, retromuscular prefascial mesh placement offers superior infection control despite higher perioperative bleeding risk. The technique demonstrates excellent outcomes with zero recurrence rates, making it a preferred approach for experienced surgeons managing appropriately selected patients with incisional hernias.
Downloads
Metrics
References
Le Huu Nho R, Mege D, Ouaïssi M, Sielezneff I, Sastre B. Incidence and prevention of ventral incisional hernia. J Visc Surg. 2012;149:e3-14.
Ahn BK, Lim KT, Choi JW, Lee KG, Lee SI, Kim CH. Risk factors for incisional hernia and parastomal hernia after colorectal surgery. J Korean Soc Coloproctol. 2012;28(6):280-286.
Hodgkinson JD, Leo CA, Maeda Y, Bassett P, Oke SM, Vaizey CJ, et al. A meta-analysis comparing laparoscopic vs open mesh repair for parastomal hernia. Colorectal Dis. 2013;15(2):e90-e96.
Millikan KW. Incisional hernia repair. Surg Clin North Am. 2003;83(5):1223-1234.
van't Riet M, Steyerberg EW, Nellensteyn J, Bonjer HJ, Jeekel J. Meta-analysis of techniques for closure of midline abdominal incisions. Br J Surg. 2002;89(11):1350-1356.
Read RC, Yoder G. Recent trends in the management of incisional herniation. Arch Surg. 1989;124(4):485-488.
Luijendijk RW, Hop WC, van den Tol MP, et al. A comparison of suture repair with mesh repair for incisional hernia. N Engl J Med. 2000;343(6):392-398.
Rives J, Pire JC, Flament JB, Palot JP. Treatment of large ventral hernias with the "dacron patch" technique. Chirurgie. 1973;99(8):547-563.
Stoppa RE. The treatment of complicated groin and incisional hernias. World J Surg. 1989;13(5):545-554.
Burger JW, Luijendijk RW, Hop WC, Halm JA, Verdaasdonk EG, Jeekel J. Long-term follow-up of a randomized controlled trial of suture versus mesh repair of incisional hernia. Ann Surg. 2004;240(4):578-583.
Sevinç B, Okuş A, Ay S, Aksoy N, Karahan Ö. Randomized prospective comparison of long-term results of onlay and sublay mesh repair techniques for incisional hernia. Turk J Surg. 2018;34(1):17-20.
Machairas A, Misiakos EP, Liakakos T, Karatzas G. Incisional hernioplasty with extraperitoneal onlay mesh placement. Hernia. 2004;8(2):115-119.
Akinci M, Ergul Z, Kaya O, Kulah B, Kulacoglu H. Predictors for duration of hospital stay after abdominal wall hernia repairs. Chirurgia (Bucur). 2012;107(1):47-51.
Korenkov M, Paul A, Sauerland S, et al. Classification and surgical treatment of incisional hernia. Results of an experts' meeting. Langenbecks Arch Surg. 2001;386(1):65-73.
Ramshaw BJ, Esartia P, Schwab J, et al. Comparison of laparoscopic and open ventral herniorrhaphy. Am Surg. 1999;65(9):827-831.
Wantz GE. Incisional hernioplasty with Mersilene. Surg Gynecol Obstet. 1991;172(2):129-137.
Horan TC, Gaynes RP, Martone WJ, Jarvis WR, Emori TG. CDC definitions of nosocomial surgical site infections, 1992: a modification of CDC definitions of surgical wound infections. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 1992;13(10):606-608.
Payne JH Jr, Grininger LM, Izawa MT, Podoll EF, Lindahl PJ, Balfour J. Laparoscopic or open inguinal herniorrhaphy? A randomized prospective trial. Arch Surg. 1994;129(9):973-979.
Jenkins ED, Yom VH, Melman L, et al. Clinical predictors of operative complexity in laparoscopic ventral hernia repair: a prospective study. Surg Endosc. 2010;24(8):1872-1877.
Heniford BT, Park A, Ramshaw BJ, Voeller G. Laparoscopic repair of ventral hernias: nine years' experience with 850 consecutive hernias. Ann Surg. 2003;238(3):391-399.
Carbajo MA, del Olmo JC, Blanco JI, et al. Laparoscopic treatment vs open surgery in the solution of major incisional and abdominal wall hernias with mesh. Surg Endosc. 1999;13(3):250-252.
Park A, Birch DW, Lovrics P. Laparoscopic and open incisional hernia repair: a comparison study. Surgery. 1998;124(4):816-821.
Conze J, Klinge U, Schumpelick V. Noncompliance in follow-up investigations after incisional hernia repair with Marlex mesh. Am J Surg. 1995;170(4):351-356.
Klosterhalfen B, Junge K, Klinge U. The lightweight and large porous mesh concept for hernia repair. Expert Rev Med Devices. 2005;2(1):103-117.
Heartsill L, Richards ML, Arfaei A, Lee EI, Meyer TA, Strodel WE. Open Rives-Stoppa ventral hernia repair made simple and successful but not for everyone. Hernia. 2005;9(2):162-166.
Bauk JJ, Harrin MT, Georgeson KE, Ponsky TA. Minimally invasive repair of incisional hernias in children. J Pediatr Surg. 2007;42(12):2071-2074.
Venclauskas L, Maleckas A, Kiudelis M. One-year follow-up after incisional hernia treatment: results of a prospective randomized study. Hernia. 2010;14(6):575-582.
Cassar K, Munro A. Surgical treatment of incisional hernia. Br J Surg. 2002;89(5):534-545.
Kingsnorth A, LeBlanc K. Hernias: inguinal and incisional. Lancet. 2003;362(9395):1561-1571.
Amid PK. Classification of biomaterials and their related complications in abdominal wall hernia surgery. Hernia. 1997;1(1):15-21.
Bhutia WT, Laishram RS, Thoudam Y, Singh KJ, Singh TT, Singh AM. A prospective study on different techniques of incisional hernia repair and their outcome. Int Surg J. 2017;4(8):2569-2574.
Mudge M, Hughes LE. Incisional hernia: a 10 year prospective study of incidence and attitudes. Br J Surg. 1985;72(1):70-71.
Ellis H, Gajraj H, George CD. Incisional hernias: when do they occur? Br J Surg. 1983;70(5):290-291.
Hesselink VJ, Luijendijk RW, de Wilt JH, Heide R, Jeekel J. An evaluation of risk factors in incisional hernia recurrence. Surg Gynecol Obstet. 1993;176(3):228-234.
Hadchity Y, Naccache N, Bou Khalil P, et al. Retromuscular versus onlay mesh repair for the treatment of incisional hernia: a retrospective comparative study. Hernia. 2016;20(5):649-655.
Saber A, Ellabban GM, Gad MA, Elsayem K. Open preperitoneal versus posterior sheath mesh repair for incisional hernia: a comparative study. Surg Today. 2010;40(9):849-853.
Ponka JL. Hernias of the abdominal wall. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 1980.
Goel TC, Dubey PC. Abdominal wall reconstruction for large ventral hernia with polypropylene mesh. Indian J Surg. 2003;65(3):242-246.
Machairas A, Liakakos T, Misiakos EP, et al. Prosthetic repair of incisional hernia. Hernia. 2001;5(4):196-199.
de Vries Reilingh TS, van Geldere D, Langenhorst B, et al. Repair of large midline incisional hernias with polypropylene mesh: comparison of three operative techniques. Hernia. 2004;8(1):56-59.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
You are free to:
- Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
- Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Terms:
- Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
- No additional restrictions — You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.
